UPSC Exam > UPSC Questions > Which of the following statements are not co...
Start Learning for Free
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee?
1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States
2. The question of sovereignty was left undefined
- a)1 Only
- b)2 Only
- c)Both of them
- d)Neither of them
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
| FREE This question is part of | Download PDF Attempt this Test |
Most Upvoted Answer
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler commit...
- Definition of extent of sovereignty and paramountcy was still undefined. The Butler committee was set up to examine the relationship between the princely states and the government.
- It gave the following recommendations-
- 1. Paramountcy must remain supreme and must fulfil its obligations, adopting and defining itself according to the shifting necessities of time and states' progressive development.
- 2. States should not be handed over to an Indian Government in British India, responsible to an Indian legislature, without the consent of states.
- Thus, "paramountcy" was left undefined and this hydra-headed creature was left to feed on usage, Crown's prerogative and the princes' implied consent.
Free Test
FREE
| Start Free Test |
Community Answer
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler commit...
The correct answer is option 'A': 1 Only.
Explanation:
The Butler Committee, also known as the Indian States Committee, was appointed by the British Government in 1927 to examine the issues related to the relationship between the princely states and the British Indian government. The committee was headed by Sir Harcourt Butler.
1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States:
The Butler Committee did recommend that the princely states should not be handed over to an Indian government without their consent. This was in line with the British policy of maintaining the autonomy of the princely states and respecting their individual treaties with the British Crown. The committee recognized the importance of the consent of the princely states in any future transfer of power.
2. The question of sovereignty was left undefined:
Contrary to the statement, the Butler Committee did not leave the question of sovereignty undefined. In fact, the committee addressed the issue of sovereignty and paramountcy. Paramountcy referred to the relationship between the princely states and the British Crown, where the British Crown had the ultimate authority and control over the princely states. The committee defined paramountcy and recommended that it should continue until a suitable alternative arrangement was made.
The committee recognized the importance of the princely states and their rulers in the process of constitutional reforms and the transfer of power. It emphasized the need for their consent and cooperation in any future political arrangements. However, it also acknowledged the changing political scenario and the rising demands for self-government in British India.
In conclusion, the correct statement is option 'A': 1 Only. The Butler Committee did recommend that the princely states should not be handed over to an Indian government without their consent. However, it did not leave the question of sovereignty undefined and instead addressed the issue of sovereignty and paramountcy.
Explanation:
The Butler Committee, also known as the Indian States Committee, was appointed by the British Government in 1927 to examine the issues related to the relationship between the princely states and the British Indian government. The committee was headed by Sir Harcourt Butler.
1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States:
The Butler Committee did recommend that the princely states should not be handed over to an Indian government without their consent. This was in line with the British policy of maintaining the autonomy of the princely states and respecting their individual treaties with the British Crown. The committee recognized the importance of the consent of the princely states in any future transfer of power.
2. The question of sovereignty was left undefined:
Contrary to the statement, the Butler Committee did not leave the question of sovereignty undefined. In fact, the committee addressed the issue of sovereignty and paramountcy. Paramountcy referred to the relationship between the princely states and the British Crown, where the British Crown had the ultimate authority and control over the princely states. The committee defined paramountcy and recommended that it should continue until a suitable alternative arrangement was made.
The committee recognized the importance of the princely states and their rulers in the process of constitutional reforms and the transfer of power. It emphasized the need for their consent and cooperation in any future political arrangements. However, it also acknowledged the changing political scenario and the rising demands for self-government in British India.
In conclusion, the correct statement is option 'A': 1 Only. The Butler Committee did recommend that the princely states should not be handed over to an Indian government without their consent. However, it did not leave the question of sovereignty undefined and instead addressed the issue of sovereignty and paramountcy.
Attention UPSC Students!
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed UPSC study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in UPSC.
|
Explore Courses for UPSC exam
|
|
Top Courses for UPSCView all
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for UPSC 2024 is part of UPSC preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the UPSC exam syllabus. Information about Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for UPSC 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for UPSC 2024 is part of UPSC preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the UPSC exam syllabus. Information about Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for UPSC 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for UPSC.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for UPSC Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice Which of the following statements are not correct about Butler committee? 1. By defining paramountcy, it recommended that States should not be handed over to an Indian government in British India without the consent of States 2. The question of sovereignty was left undefineda) 1 Onlyb) 2 Onlyc) Both of themd) Neither of themCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice UPSC tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for UPSC exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
Follow Us
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup